Quality Management, Christianity, and Citizenship. What does IU Football and Basketball Free-throw Shooting Have to Do With It?

Quality Leadership involves leveraging the interdependencies between Citizenship, Quality Management, and Christianity. The result leads to more responsible citizenship, stronger families, communities, and country.

 

We often view sports, faith, and local governance as entirely separate worlds. But at the heart of all three lies a hidden truth that determines success or failure: how we manage systemic variation.

The contributions of W. Edwards Deming in developing and introducing a new system for managing quality were recognized by Fortune magazine as “among the 20 that have shaped the modern world of business,” and by U.S. News and World Report as “one of nine turning points in history. The top turning point was identified as the Apostle Paul, whose preaching and eloquent writings led to the mass acceptance of Christianity.”

Deming concluded that if he were to reduce his message to just a few words, it all has to do with reducing variation. Ignorance of this fundamental truth is why the contributions of W. Edwards Deming are not more commonly known or understood.

Men occasionally stumble over the truth, but most of them pick themselves up and hurry off as if nothing had happened. – Winston Churchill

Through his survey regarding a Biblical World View, George Barna reports that only 4% claim “religious beliefs and worldview-related behaviors … consistent with biblical principles, beliefs and behavior.”

  • The 10 Commandments reinforce God’s foundation of a biblical worldview.
  • A biblical worldview refers to an understanding of the core principles and beliefs of Christianity. A Christian would strive to live according to these beliefs and repent when they fall short, while understanding that, through God’s grace, they will be forgiven as they forgive others.
  • To be an effective Christian or Citizen, a biblical worldview is not enough by itself to navigate successfully in today’s world.
  • A quality management system provides a context that integrates a biblical worldview with citizenship. Judeo-Christian principles informed the Declaration of Independence and influenced the design of the Constitution.

A survey regarding the relevance of Quality Management to a biblical worldview could be assessed with one question:

How would you define the ideal basketball free-throw shot?

I’ve asked this question numerous times over the years, and the most common and incomplete answer is “it goes in.” But a perfect free throw isn’t just about the result; it would include where the ball lands, along with the speed, motion, and trajectory. An explanation and accompanying article are provided at SuccessThroughQuality.com, Articles, Research Papers, Posts – Continuous Improvement at the Free-Throw Line.

Using another sports metaphor, the success of Indiana University football coach Kurt Cignetti in achieving a perfect record, including winning the national championship, represents a successful application of an intuitive or a more unconscious awareness and understanding of variation.

Can Cignetti’s system be successfully reverse-engineered? Yes, and understanding variation would make it easier. Cignetti succeeded because he didn’t just focus on winning games (the result), but on relentlessly standardizing and improving processes and systems. Culture is a supporting system, and the Leader (coach) is the “conductor of the orchestra (system).

“An example of a system well-optimized, is a good orchestra.” – WED

Successfully leveraging the interrelationship between Citizenship, Christianity, and Quality management supports continuous improvement.

For Christian, understanding and managing vocation helps to avoid the Sin of Omission.

Anyone, then, who knows the right thing to do and fails to do it, commits sin. – James 4:17

In organizations, failing to adopt better methods to reduce variation results in higher costs to customers and society. Deming described the cycle as a Chain Reaction:

  • When you improve quality by reducing variation, Costs decrease because of less rework, fewer mistakes, fewer delays and snags, better use of time and materials; productivity improves; capture the market with better quality and lower prices; stay in business; and provide more jobs.

Further Explanations

  • Variation is an inherent part of God’s design of the universe.
  • Variation represents the difference between the ideal (perfect) and the actual situation
  • Perfect is described as encompassing all human needs, including those that support physical, psychological, and spiritual health. The more needs are met, the less harm is caused by unmet needs. Consequently, continuous improvement becomes a moral imperative.
  • In Quality Management, the concept (things either get better or worse) is supported by the Taguchi Loss Function, which reinforces that the closer any service or product meets the ideal (target, more perfect), the higher the quality and the lower the cost to the individual and society.
  • All actions are accomplished through a process (a habit, routine). A system is a collection of processes with a common aim. Example: (Commuting to work or school is a process that is not possible without the existence of a transportation system. The transportation system includes the means of travel, infrastructure, laws and regulations, emergency services, etc.)

Systems determine most, if not all, of the results. A system is a collection of processes with a common aim. The U.S. Founding Fathers identified the aim of the Constitution to enable We the People (top management) to work together to achieve “a more perfect Union.”

Tasks, Processes, Systems

In the military, a process is an individual task needed to develop skills, knowledge, and abilities (See Universal Joint Task List). Collective tasks are all the individual tasks needed to accomplish a respective mission. Same principle in Sports: You have the individual tasks for each position and the collective tasks needed to support the overall game plan. The key to execution is the leadership and culture.

Conclusion

Ultimately, systems determine results. If we want a society—and a local government—to achieve the highest levels of quality possible, we must adopt the methods required to reduce variation and eliminate systemic waste.

From the discipline of Coach Cignetti’s gridiron to the foundational targets set by the Ten Commandments, the lesson is clear: quality is a continuous journey. By accepting our role as the “top management” of our communities, we can replace chaotic variation with a disciplined, continuous effort toward a more perfect union.

The Founders left it up to future generations—including our own—to accept responsibility for this journey, applying the best methods available to improve systemic quality in our own backyards. Continuous improvement is no longer just a management strategy; it is a moral imperative.

End Notes:

ChatGPT Prompt and Replies – Ten Commandments, Five Whys, Taguchi Loss Function, Metics, Example

PDF: ChatGPT Five Whys, Commandments, Taguchi Loss Funtion

  • The Five Whys is a root cause analysis tool developed in quality management. When applied to the Ten Commandments, it can help uncover the deeper principles behind each commandment, rather than viewing them merely as rules, but as a System.
  • System View: The Ten Commandments can be viewed as defining the Target Condition for Society. This identifies why each target matters. The Taguchi Loss Function explains the consequences of deviation.
  • Feedback Measures: This is where the framework becomes especially useful from a Deming, Taguchi, and systems-thinking perspective.
  • Applied Example – Local level of Government – Brown County, IN

Memorial Day and the American Experiment

Memorial Day is a time to remember the men and women who made the ultimate sacrifice to defend our Constitution and way of life. Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address conveyed both gratitude and responsibility, calling citizens to “highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain.”

Our family was blessed that relatives who served in World War II, Korea, Vietnam, the Gulf War, and the Global War on Terror survived their service, returned home, raised families, and lived productive lives.

My father served in Korea, which sparked my interest in military history — how wars are fought. That interest eventually led me to political theory — why nations go to war — and then to biblical history and the deeper question of why people conflict with one another in the first place.

Early in my career, I attended a four-day seminar led by W. Edwards Deming, whose work on quality improvement transformed industries around the world. Deming often summarized his philosophy with a simple statement: “It all has to do with reducing variation.”

It took me years to appreciate the depth of that insight. Over time, I came to see how the principle of reducing harmful variation connects Citizenship, Quality Management, and both secular and Christian approaches to learning and continuous improvement.

This year marks the 250th anniversary of the American experiment in self-government. Events such as the Freedom 250 Rally at the National Mall highlighted the influence of Judeo-Christian principles on the Constitution and the ongoing challenge of helping “We the People” work toward a more perfect union.

In a perfect world, all human needs would be met. In our imperfect world, progress requires continual learning, better methods, and the willingness to reduce the gap between our ideals and our actions.

For atheists, agnostics, Christians, and non-Christians alike, that shared pursuit of improvement may represent important common ground. The deeper question is what ultimately defines the moral standard and motivates people to pursue it: man, God, or some combination of both.

After retiring, I began volunteering and attending county government meetings. After more than seven years and over 400 meetings, I decided to run successfully for county commissioner. Through my websites and Substack, I continue sharing ideas aimed at improving quality not only in national government, but also at the local level where citizens can make a direct difference.

As America approaches its 250th anniversary, this may be an ideal time to renew our commitment to learning, citizenship, and the continuous work of building a more perfect union.

Rededicate 250: A National Jubilee of Prayer, Praise & Thanksgiving

Watch on YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BG5ivxgzpu8

Exclusive: Bishop Barron on the 250th Anniversary of the US & More | EWTN News Special

Freedom 250 Invites All Americans to Come Together in Prayer and Worship Ahead of the Nation’s 250th Birthday.

Three Pillars of the Day

Pillar I — The Miracles that Made Us: A reflection on God’s providence throughout 250 years, honoring the faith that inspired America’s founders and has carried us forward in every generation since.

Pillar II — The Miracles Still in Our Midst: Personal testimonies of God’s healing in our lives and in our land.

Pillar III — A New Birth of Faith and Freedom: A collective expression of gratitude for 250 years of freedom — and a unified moment of rededication asking for God’s blessing, guidance, and grace for the next 250.

Event Details

Date: Sunday, May 17, 2026

Time: 9:00 AM Gates Open

10:30 AM-6:00 PM Full Program

Location: National Mall, Washington, D.C. — Main Stage at 12th Street

Special Guests, Speakers, & Performers

Public Leadership

Faith Leaders

Authors, Media, & Witnesses

Musical & Ceremonial

Special Guests, Speakers, & Performers

Public Leadership

  • Speaker Mike Johnson 56th Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives
  • Secretary Marco Rubio 72nd United States Secretary of State
  • Secretary Pete Hegseth 29th United States Secretary of War
  • Senator Tim Scott United States Senator from South Carolina
  • Ambassador Monica Crowley 35th Chief of Protocol of the United States
  • Dr. Ben Carson Founder and Chairman of the American Cornerstone Institute, Former U.S. Secretary of Housing and Urban Development and renowned neurosurgeon
  • Major General Patrick Brady, USA (Ret.) Medal of Honor Recipient and retired United States Army Major General
  • Dr. Larry Arnn 12th President of Hillsdale College

Faith Leaders

  • U.S. Military Chaplain Corps
  • Franklin Graham President and CEO of Samaritan’s Purse and the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association
  • Bishop Robert Barron Bishop of the Diocese of Winona–Rochester and Founder of Word on Fire Catholic Ministries
  • Cardinal Timothy Dolan Archbishop Emeritus of the Archdiocese of New York and Former President of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops
  • Pastor Jack Graham Senior Pastor of Prestonwood Baptist Church
  • Pastor Jentezen Franklin Senior Pastor of Free Chapel, New York Times Bestselling Author, and Host of the “Kingdom Connection”
  • Pastor Jonathan Falwell Chancellor of Liberty University and Senior Pastor of Thomas Road Baptist Church
  • Pastor Samuel Rodriguez Lead Pastor of New Season Church and President of the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference
  • Rabbi Meir Soloveichik Senior Rabbi of Congregation Shearith Israel in New York City
  • Dr. Robert Jeffress Senior Pastor of First Baptist Dallas
  • Pastor Jonathan ”JP” Pokluda Lead Pastor of Harris Creek Baptist Church, Author, and Host of the “Becoming Something Podcast”
  • Gordon P. Robertson Chancellor of Regent University and President of Christian Broadcasting Network
  • Pastor Paula White Senior Advisor to the White House Faith Office
  • Apostle Guillermo Mondonaldo Founder and Senior Pastor of El Rey Jesus
  • Pastor Lorenzo Sewell Senior Pastor of 180 Church in Detroit
  • Pastor Lou Engles Co-Founder of TheCall and Founder of Lou Engle Ministries
  • Pastor Gary Hamrick Senior Pastor of Cornerstone Chapel and radio host
  • Bishop Kelvin Cobaris Lead Pastor of New Life Church International
  • Pastor Andy Deane Lead Pastor of Cornerstone Community Church
  • Andy Frank  Pastor and Worship Leader

Authors, Media, & Witnesses

  • Jonathan Roumie Renowned Actor, The Chosen and the 2023 film Jesus Revolution
  • Eric Metaxas New York Times Best Selling Author and Host of The Eric Metaxas Show
  • Sadie Robertson Huff  Founder of LO Worship and Host of WHOA That’s Good Podcast
  • Dr. Alveda C. King Niece of Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr, Founder of Speak for Life, American activist, Author, and Former State Representative for the 28th District in the Georgia House of Representatives
  • Cissie Graham Lynch Author and ministry leader with Samaritan’s Purse and the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association
  • Abigail Robertson  Co-Host of the CBN Podcast “Heaven Meets Earth” and Producer of the documentary “The Revival Generation”

Musical & Ceremonial

  • Chris Tomlin Grammy-winning American contemporary Christian Artist and Worship Leader
  • Blessing Offor Nigerian-born American gospel and contemporary Christian music singer and songwriter
  • Aodhan King Worship Leader, Songwriter, and Founding Member of the Grammy-nominated Christian music group Hillsong Young & Free
  • Laura Osnes feat. Joint Armed Forces Color Guard “Two-time Tony Award Nominee, Actress, and Singer”
  • Liberty Worship Collective and Liberty University Praise
  • The Grand Canyon University Canyon Choral Society
  • The Hillsdale College Choir
  • ‘”The President’’s Own” United States Marine Band’
  • The United States Navy Band
  • Fanfare Trumpets of the United States Armed Forces
  • SMSgt Adam Tianello and the United States Air Force Band

Join with neighbors and friends from every state in the Union in giving thanks and praise to God for 250 years of His Providence for the United States, in praying that God Bless and Protect America for the next 250 years, and in solemnly rededicating our country as One Nation under God. In speech, song, and storytelling, we will bear witness to the extraordinary story of how God has powerfully and wondrously shaped the United States of America—remembering the people, sacrifices, and defining moments in which God has powerfully manifested Himself in our history.

This is more than an event — it is a once in a lifetime national moment.

 

Human Rights and the Greatest Evil?

Bill Maher Reveals Why He’s Harder on Dems Today...and It Was Something, Matt Vespa, Townhall

“The comedian didn’t hold back about his feelings on the recent shift within the Democratic Party. Until they address this problem, he’ll keep criticizing his own side of the aisle. If you go on Maher’s show believing that Israel is the greatest evil of all time, he will tear you apart. This New Rules segment makes it clear: if you share that view, you’re historically illiterate in the extreme (via RealClearPolitics):”

Transcript

And finally, new rules since yesterday was Israel’s birthday. Having become a nation on May 14th, 78 years ago, everyone must either wish her a happy birthday or admit they’re anti-Semitic. Now, it’s everyone’s right in a free country to be anti-Semitic, but enough with hiding behind Israel or Zionism or Netanyahu.

If you think, as so many do now, that when it comes to human rights, Israel is the monster country of all time, you either don’t read or you don’t care about your own hypocrisy. Because there are so many worse places. But that’s where we are these days.

No Jews, no news. Ha ha. But China, Russia, Sudan, Iran, Myanmar, Haiti, the Congo, North Korea, all way worse.

And that’s how you know it’s anti-Semitism. It’s the inconsistency. People talk about Jews these days like something out of Stormfront, except it’s not Stormfront.

It’s an editor from the American Prospect, which is a venerable liberal publication that launched the careers of journalists like Ezra Klein. And yet no one blinks when one of their editors says, Israel is a brainwashed, psychopathic death cult that might need to be nuked to save the human race. Uh-huh.

People say the left and the right can’t agree on anything these days. Well, there is this one thing they agree on. Right-winger Tucker Carlson has Nick Fuentes and Holocaust deniers on his podcast and wonders along with them, who really was the bad guy in World War II?

And the New York Times has on their podcast super leftist Hasan Piker, who they call a progressive mind, and who says Zionists should be treated the same as Nazis, which I assume means hung at Nuremberg. That’s what progressive is now? I guess so.

The kids are sure into it. They went nuts last year at Coachella for Kneecap. That’s the name of an Irish rap group, as if Ireland hasn’t suffered enough.

Their stage set is a sign that says, f*ck Israel. And then they send a beach ball around the crowd. Again, ha-ha.

Because again, Israel is the only country in the world doing anything bad. I see why the Meathead Manosphere and the Code Pink people are on the same page. Because they both went to high school in America and they don’t know anything.

So we… So we really could someday soon have the tiki torch Jews will not replace us crowd and the queers for Palestine people working together to elect the next Hitler. There’s a North Carolina teenager who’s been charged with plotting to drive through a synagogue to fulfill her life goal of killing as many Jews as possible.

Because a kid’s got to have a dream. I’m just asking why in the world would this be the dream of some kid in North Carolina? Why is it the dream of Dan Bilzerian, who’s running as a Republican to win a House seat in Florida?

Who’s Dan Bilzerian? Well, he’s a professional douchebag who’s attracted 30 million followers by doing this all day and posting it. Yes, he’ll fit in fine with the current Congress.

And Dan is fairly typical of the guys in the Manosphere when he says the only real battle in the world today that I see worth fighting is f*cking, you know, exterminating Israel. I mean, I would sign up tomorrow to go f*cking put boots on the ground and go f*cking kill Israelis. Why?

Why is this a**hole’s life about two things? Getting more Viagra and exterminating the Jews. Israel was founded on the idea that anti-Semitism made a Jewish state unnecessary because Jews would never be safe without one.

Can you honestly listen to this rhetoric and not see why that turned out to be true? If you don’t have the right-wingers on your side, if you don’t have the progressives, what do you have? What’s more progressive than college, where professors now say things that would make Kanye wince?

Osman Umarji calls Zionists bloodthirsty animals. Who’s he, the leader of ISIS? No, he’s a professor right here in California at UC Irvine.

And Candace Owens agrees with his assessment of Jews as animals because she says wherever they go, they bring their filth with them. Another professor, Hamid Dabashi, says of Israels, they have a vulgarity of character that is bone-deep and structural to the skeletal vertebrae of its culture. These are the kind of statements Goebbels would have read and said, no notes.

I mean, where are the Jewish space lasers when you need them? Now, there are absolutely horrible things said about Muslims, too. That should also be, of course, roundly condemned, like Republican Congressman Randy Fine saying, if they force us to choose, the choice between dogs and Muslims is not a difficult one.

That’s awful. But it’s not the same as they need to be nuked and let’s exterminate them. This is why Jewish people here and in Europe now say they sometimes hide their identity, afraid that the Star of David will get them attacked, as has happened in almost too many places to mention lately.

Leave your Star of David at home. But the keffiyeh? You can wear that anywhere.

You can wear it to Fiddler on the Roof and you’ll get applause. Jew hatred isn’t just acceptable now, it’s cool. Celebrities love it and make it trendy.

It’s the new Che Guevara T-shirt. The Islamophobia is just as bad argument is simply a false equivalency. Can you name a Jewish professor who talks about Muslims the way they get talked about?

No. Anti-Jewish crimes, hate crimes, now outpace anti-Muslim hate crimes 9 to 1. It’s not a contest, and I’m certainly not saying do more of the other.

I’m just saying these are the numbers, the facts, the reality. There is a frothing anxiousness for the literal extermination of this one group. And Democrats, where are you?

If any other minority group was being talked about this way, you’d break out the kente cloth and have ten benefit concerts. But because you see that so many of your brainwashed-by-TikTok constituents now have an unfavorable view of Israel, you indulge them when you should be correcting them. You don’t tell your woke idiots Israel isn’t a colonizer or an apartheid state or committing genocide, and that if you brats had to spend a week anywhere in the Middle East other than Israel, you would understand what liberalism is not.

All the people likely running for president now on the Democratic side want it known they don’t take money from AIPAC, the Israeli lobby, a stanch which gives permission to actual anti-Semites to say, see, we’re right about Israel. That’s dirty money from a dirty country. Oh, please, you take money from crypto and factory farmers and big tech from Diddy and Weinstein and Epstein, but AIPAC is too far?

Let me just say this to all who ask me. Why are you harder on the Democrats than you used to be? Until you fix this whole issue, stop asking me.

I’m out.

Catholic Latin Mass Explained

OREMUS: The Traditional Latin Mass Explained
The Traditional Latin Mass is not a relic of the past, it is the living heartbeat of Catholic tradition.  

In this powerful interview, Michael Matt and Father Gregory Pendergraft, FSSP, explain:

Why the Mass is in Latin

Why the priest faces the altar

Why Catholics receive Communion on the tongue How to follow and pray the ancient Roman Rite

Why the Latin Mass continues to grow around the world Discover the beauty, mystery, and reverence of the Mass that formed the saints.  

If you’ve ever wondered what makes the Latin Mass so powerful, this is the video to watch:

Strategic Coherence: Aligning Global Religious and Political Interests

In Matthew 18:15-20, Jesus outlines a specific process for addressing disagreements within the community—moving from private dialogue to communal involvement. In the world of Quality Management, this mirrors the effort to resolve “variation” before it compromises the integrity of the whole system.

Marco Rubio’s meeting with the Pope on May 7, 2026, and the Political Responsibility of Catholics underscores the interrelationship between Christianity and Citizenship. The disconnects can be explained by an unconscious awareness and understanding of variation that can be developed through the application of the quality improvement principles, methods, and some tools.

Rubio’s broader objective in achieving a more ideal outcome, as identified by Bepi Pezzulli | in his article, Marco Rubio In Rome: Vatican Symbolism And Strategic Friction,” is domestic as much as diplomatic:

  • reunifying the Christian electorate—evangelicals and Catholics alike—around the civilizational language of the West, order, and religious continuity.
  • If the Church is to retain a political role at all, in his view, it should be as custodian of Western civilization rather than as chaplain to militant third-worldism disguised as moral universalism.

Alignment: Christianity, Citizenship, Quality Management

Christianity. God is Love. Love is an action – willing the good of others in thoughts, words, and actions. Perfection is described as all needs being met, thereby reducing the harm caused to people by unmet needs. Consequently, continuous improvement is a moral imperative.

  • Abraham Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs
  • In a commercial sense, any product or service provided to a customer is intended to meet a need. Needs include the physical, mental, psychological, and spiritual aspects that contribute to well-being.Indirectly, every business and every employee can be in support of God’s plan to improve the lives of others.

Citizenship. The U.S. Constitution was designed to enable We the People (top management) through checks and balances on power, to work together in working towards “a more perfect Union.

Quality Management. The aim of quality management is to reduce variation – the gap between the ideal (more perfect) and the actual situation. The Taguchi Loss Function reinforces that the closer any product or service gets to the ideal or target, the higher the quality and profitability, and the lower the cost to the customer and society.

Just as variation in manufacturing leads to loss for society, a lack of ‘strategic coherence’ between religious values and political action creates a societal cost—what Rubio identifies as the weakening of Western order.

Marco Rubio In Rome: Vatican Symbolism And Strategic Friction

Rubio’s Rome message was not conciliatory, but disciplinary, by Bepi Pezzulli | May 12, 2026, The American Thinker

  • The meeting was not about reconciliation, but for realignment. It reflected the Secretary of State’s understanding of a broader ecclesiastical and political transition inside the Catholic Church.
  • Rubio, himself a practicing Catholic, approaches the issue with conceptual clarity. When the Pope speaks as spiritual shepherd, he commands respect as a religious authority. When he speaks as a temporal sovereign advancing geopolitical preferences, he enters ordinary political debate and weakens the universal nature of his office.
  • Rubio’s broader objective is domestic as much as diplomatic: reunifying the Christian electorate—evangelicals and Catholics alike—around the civilizational language of the West, order, and religious continuity. If the Church is to retain a political role at all, in his view, it should be as custodian of Western civilization rather than as chaplain to militant third-worldism disguised as moral universalism

Frameworks for Action: Faithful Citizenship

United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB): Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship

The Catholic bishops of the United States are pleased to offer once again to the Catholic faithful Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship (en Español), our teaching document on the political responsibility of Catholics. This statement represents our guidance for Catholics in the exercise of their rights and duties as participants in our democracy. We urge our pastors, lay and religious faithful, and all people of good will to use this statement to help form their consciences; to teach those entrusted to their care; to contribute to civil and respectful public dialogue; and to shape political choices in the coming election in light of Catholic teaching. The statement lifts up our dual heritage as both faithful Catholics and American citizens with rights and duties as participants in the civil order.

Ultimately, achieving “Strategic Coherence” is not just a task for diplomats; it is the work of every “Faithful Citizen.” To help bridge the gap between the ideal of the Gospel and the reality of political life, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) provides a robust framework in Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship.

By treating these teachings as a guide to “reducing variation” in our own civic lives, we can better align our actions with our values.

How do you see the principles of quality management—specifically the reduction of variation—applying to your own roles as both a person of faith and a citizen?

Learn More

Read Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship: A Call to Political Responsibility from the Catholic Bishops of the United States (en Español), which provides a framework for Catholics in the United States. (English PDF | PDF en Español)

As a complement to Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship, the bishops also approved six new bulletin inserts (en Español) to help the Catholic faithful put their faith into action.  

 

Marco Rubio: the Catholic Roots of America

Secretary of State Marco Rubio delivers virtual address at CIT’s Conference, Endowed by Their Creator: Catholicism, the Declaration of Independence, and the American Experiment at 250

On Thursday, April 9th, Catholic Law’s Center for the Constitution and the Catholic Intellectual Tradition, together with Notre Dame’s Center for Citizenship and Constitutional Government and Catholic University’s Carroll Forum for Citizenship and Public Life, co-hosted a symposium celebrating the nation’s semiquincentennial. The day brought together leading scholars and public intellectuals from across the country to explore the relationship between the Catholic intellectual tradition and the principles of the Declaration of Independence, and to reflect on how both Catholicism and the Declaration continue to shape America’s experiment in constitutional self-government, 250 years after its founding.

Marco Rubio on Catholicism:

In 1895, Pope Leo XIII penned an encyclical to the Catholic Church in the United States. 

“All intelligent men are agreed,” he wrote, “that America seems destined for greater things. Now, it is our wish that the Catholic Church should not only share in, but help to bring about this prospective greatness.” 

But, as the Holy Father noted, the Church had already been here from the start. Four centuries prior, one Catholic explorer ventured out into the great unknown and returned home with the story, as he wrote in one letter, “of a land more richly endowed than I know or am able to say.” 

Few moments in history have carried more consequence. Christopher Columbus renewed the West’s confidence in itself and launched that great age of discovery, exploration, and expansion from which America was born. 

Some have claimed that the Catholic faith is a foreign import to our country. Only one of the 56 men who signed the Declaration of Independence was Catholic—Charles Carroll of Maryland, for whom one of this conference’s hosts is named. Just two Catholic names appear on our Constitution itself. 

But the Catholic faith has always been part of the American story. The first Christian service on our soil was a Catholic Mass. The oldest permanent settlement in the United States is the town of St. Augustine, planted by Spanish Catholics on the coastal sands of my home state of Florida. 

Catholic saints were martyred on American soil well over a century before the Revolution began. In missions and settlements, wilderness forts, and trading posts stretching from the first colonies to the distant frontier, Catholic explorers, soldiers, priests, and pioneers consecrated this new world to their ancient faith and christened its land with Catholic names—Maryland, St. Louis, San Francisco, Santa Fe. Almost every region of what is now the United States was first explored and mapped by Catholics. 

This is no coincidence. Christianity taught the West to think in continents and centuries, rather than villages and seasons. The Church calls us, as Christ told St. Peter, “to duc in altum,” to put out into the deep. Catholics across time have answered the call—from the forests of pagan Europe to the wilderness of North America—to bring new worlds to Christ. 

This is the inheritance which has shaped our pioneer nation: the spirit of expansion and discovery which would conquer continents, unlock the mysteries of the universe, and eventually transcend the limits of Earth itself. It is the same spirit that led 56 Americans to pledge their lives, fortunes, and sacred honor to each other in the cause of independence two and a half centuries ago. 

Catholics in the colonies flocked to join them, enlisting to fight for the patriots at a rate far exceeding their share of the population. In 1790, George Washington wrote to the Roman Catholics of America to thank them personally “for the patriotic part which you took in the accomplishments of the revolution.” 

It is popular today to claim the founding was merely a brainchild of the Enlightenment, but the Revolution was not a radical rupture with the past. It was a renewal of an older inheritance fitted to the unique experience of a free, Christian people in the new world. 

That inheritance draws upon the ancient liberties of the English Constitution and common law, but it roots these traditions upon a fixed and unchanging moral order governed by the laws of nature and nature’s God. This fundamental truth endows man with not just rights, but with duties. It conceives of freedom and virtue as inseparably linked. 

We see this in the structure of our political order itself, built not to sanction license, but to restrain passion, check ambition with ambition, and secure the common good. 

It is true, of course, that most of the men who wrote our founding documents were not Catholics themselves, but the system they gave us belongs to the same civilizational tradition that produced the towering cathedrals of Rome and the philosophy of Augustine and Aquinas. 

America was a gift where the Church and the civilization it made was reborn, discovering itself anew in the wilderness. It is at once modern and ancient. The men who settled and founded our country were the architects of a great rebirth, renewing the deferred dreams of the old world and the possibilities of a virgin continent. 

It has been 250 years since a new people declared themselves to the world. At the time, less than 2% were Catholic, but the nation they built would come to serve as one of the proudest and most enduring testaments to the eternal truth of our faith. 

To look upon the history of this golden land is to see the face of God. 

Variability within the Christian Faith Community

One of the differences (variation) between the Catholics and Protestants is Sola Scriptura.

  • Sola Scriptura is a Latin term meaning “Scripture alone,” which asserts that the Bible is the sole infallible authority for Christian faith and practice. This doctrine was a key principle of the Protestant Reformation, emphasizing that all necessary truth for salvation is found in Scripture. Wikipedia

Catholic Evangelization

GEMINI: What is “Apostolicam Actuositatem”?

Apostolicam Actuositatem (Decree on the Apostolate of the Laity) is a significant document from the Second Vatican Council (Vatican II), promulgated by Pope Paul VI on November 18, 1965.

It serves as the definitive guide on the role of laypeople (non-clergy) within the Catholic Church’s mission. While earlier church focus was often centered on the hierarchy, this decree emphasizes that the laity have a direct and necessary role in the “apostolate”—the work of spreading the Gospel and sanctifying the world.

Key Themes and Principles

  • The Lay Vocation: It teaches that the call to be an apostle does not come from a special appointment by a bishop, but from Baptism itself. Every Catholic is called to participate in the Church’s mission.

  • Sanctifying the Secular World: A unique aspect of the lay apostolate is its focus on the “temporal order.” This means laypeople are specifically called to bring Christian values into politics, family life, professional work, and social structures.

  • The Role of the Family: The document highlights the family as the “domestic church” and the primary place where the faith is lived and transmitted.

  • Collaboration: While asserting the independence of lay initiatives, it also stresses the importance of working in communion with the Church’s hierarchy.

Why It Matters Today

As seen on the Epistles about page, the document continues to inspire personal apostolates and digital ministries. It provides the theological foundation for “lay movements” and encourages individuals to take personal responsibility for the moral and spiritual health of their communities, rather than viewing the clergy as the sole actors in the Church.

Why It Was Revolutionary

Before Vatican II, the Church was often viewed through a “top-down” lens where the clergy were the primary actors. Apostolicam Actuositatem shifted this perspective, describing the Church as the whole People of God. It empowered laypeople to take personal responsibility for the moral and spiritual health of their communities rather than being passive recipients of the faith.

To understand how Apostolicam Actuositatem (AA) changed the landscape for laypeople, it is helpful to compare it to the “Pre-Vatican II” model of the Church. For centuries, the Church was often viewed through a strictly hierarchical lens—sometimes jokingly referred to as the “pray, pay, and obey” era for the laity.

Here is a breakdown of the fundamental shifts introduced by the decree:

1. From “Assistants” to “Apostles”

  • Before: The laity were often seen as “helpers” to the clergy. Their role was to assist the priest in his mission if he asked for it (a concept known as “Catholic Action”).

  • After (AA): The decree clarifies that the lay apostolate is a right and duty that comes from Baptism, not from a mandate by a bishop. Laypeople don’t just “help” the Church; they are the Church in the world.

2. The “Secular” as a Sacred Space

  • Before: Holiness was often associated with retreating from the world (monasticism or priesthood). The secular world (politics, business, labor) was seen as a distraction or a “lesser” sphere of spiritual importance.

  • After (AA): The decree argues that the “temporal order”—the everyday world of family and work—is the specific domain of the laity. It is their job to “infuse the Christian spirit” into these areas. A politician or a parent isn’t just living a secular life; they are performing a religious mission by seeking justice and love in those roles.

3. The Source of Authority

  • Before: Authority and mission flowed strictly from the top down. The Pope told the Bishops, who told the Priests, who told the Laity what to do.

  • After (AA): While maintaining respect for the hierarchy, AA emphasizes the “Charisms” (spiritual gifts) given to individuals by the Holy Spirit. It encourages laypeople to take the initiative and act on their own “right and duty” to spread the Gospel, rather than waiting for a specific command for every action.

4. The Church as “People of God”

  • Before: The Church was often defined by its structure—the institution and its laws.

  • After (AA): The document views the Church as a communion or the “People of God.” This shift in language suggests that every member, regardless of their rank, shares in the three-fold mission of Christ: as priest, prophet, and king.


Comparison Summary

Feature Pre-Vatican II View Apostolicam Actuositatem View
Primary Role To receive the sacraments and obey. To act as a primary witness to Christ.
Mission Field Supporting the local parish. Transforming the world (politics, work, etc.).
Identity “Non-clergy” (defined by what they are not). “Apostles” (defined by their Baptismal call).
Involvement Passive/Reactive. Active/Initiative-taking.

A breakdown of how this decree differs from the Church’s earlier views on the laity.

Justice Thomas: America’s Founding Ideals

Justice Clarence Thomas urges a return to founding ideals in speech marking America’s 250th anniversary  Justice Clarence Thomas described progressivism as a threat to the nation’s founding principles during a speech at UT Austin, and urged younger generations to stand up for their principles. (Credit: C-SPAN)

Gemini: What has Justice Thomas identified as America’s ideals?

In a special lecture at the University of Texas at Austin marking America’s 250th anniversary, Justice Clarence Thomas identified several core ideals rooted in the Declaration of Independence as the foundation of the American experiment.

He emphasized that these principles are not merely “academic playthings” or “esoteric philosophy,” but are intended to be a practical way of life for all citizens.

Core Founding Ideals

Justice Thomas highlighted three primary principles from the Declaration that he considers the “North Star” of the republic:

  • Universal Equality: The belief that all people are created equal in the image and likeness of God 15:03Opens in a new window. He noted that this equality is inherent and cannot be diminished or granted by any human government 15:13Opens in a new window.
  • Unalienable Rights: Natural rights—specifically life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness—that precede and transcend governmental authority 16:45Opens in a new window.
  • Government by Consent: The principle that government derives its legitimate power solely from the consent of the governed, with the primary purpose of securing these pre-existing rights 22:37Opens in a new window.

The “Indispensable” Final Sentence

Justice Thomas argued that the most critical part of the Declaration is often the most overlooked: the final sentence where the signers “mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes, and our sacred honor” 23:51Opens in a new window.

  • Courage as an Ideal: He defined courage not as the absence of fear, but as the assessment that these principles are more important than fear 24:34Opens in a new window.
  • Devotion: He stated that without the “last full measure of devotion”—a willingness to sacrifice personal comfort, popularity, and security—the Declaration is just “mere words on parchment paper” 25:07Opens in a new window.

 Challenges to These Ideals

Thomas issued a warning against Progressivism, which he identified as a “retrogressive” movement that opposes the founding ideals 51:06Opens in a new window. He argued that Progressivism:

Justice Thomas concluded by urging citizens to “take ownership” of their country and to defend these ideals daily—whether by speaking up in a classroom or running for a local school board—rather than sitting on the sidelines 01:31:20Opens in a new window.

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas Delivers Special Lecture at UT Austin

The University of Texas at Austin · 11K views

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas Delivers Special Lecture at UT Austin. To commemorate the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence …Opens in a new window