Fossilized Faith by Aaron Reen, Nov 14, 2025. I have a review of sociologist Christian Smith’s important new book Why Religion Went Obsolete: The Demise of Traditional Faith in America in the new December issue of First Things magazine.
“As Smith writes, obsolescence doesn’t mean extinction”. .. religion is just “less relevant to mainstream society”. Smith and Renn make the case that the “method” (“fossilized forms”—of traditional religion) of communicating the message is certainly becoming less relevant.
The topic of obsolescence is a little surreal to me. The expectations from a belief in the Christian message are timeless. God is love; love is willing the good of others, followed by taking the appropriate actions.
In the American system of government, the responsibility of citizens is to work together toward that more perfect union, which includes providing products and services as employees, entrepreneurs, elected officials, business owners, and ministers, where everyone benefits or at least, is not any worse off.
Meeting expectations requires reducing variation from the ideals advertised through promotions, marketing, and electioneering.
In a different context, how many parents and guardians who love their kids do not take the action needed to do what they think is best for them? Who doesn’t like to be the recipient of a kind word or deed?
Excellent quality results from doing the right things (effectiveness) and doing them right (efficiency). How can the management of quality ever be “obsolete”? Some people may always associate their motivation to do good with a higher power (God or a God), and others won’t – nothing new or obsolete about that. What “method” produces the best results for everyone?




The aim of the U.S. system of government is to enable We the People to work together towards “a more perfect” Union. Who defines “more perfect”?
In a biblical context, perfection is described as having all needs met (the Garden of Eden being a notable example). The more needs that are met, the less harm caused to people as a result of unmet needs.) Thus, continual improvement becomes a moral imperative for Christians.
Take the example of crime: A Christian would embrace the belief that all crime should be continually reduced. A secular belief could include that crime is an acceptable, unfortunate, or normal part of life. A run chart showing a predictable trend would provide feedback on current mitigation strategies.
Within the quality management profession, it is an accepted fact that the closer any product or service (such as crime reduction strategies) approaches the ideal or target (i.e., the more perfect it is), the higher the quality and the lower the cost to the customer and society. (Ref: Taguchi Loss Function).
So, who has “no coherent idea”?
https://lnkd.in/gfMXjiaj